Operation Something Bruin and the Federal Law of Wildlife Crime

Black bear crossing a forest road in the misty Appalachian mountains

Operation Something Bruin was a joint undercover investigation into bear poaching and related illegal hunting, conducted primarily in North Carolina and Georgia. It involved the North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission, the Georgia Department of Natural Resources, the U.S. Forest Service, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Park Service. The investigation ran from 2009, and arrests began in February 2013.

In 2013 agency announcements pointed the public to this web address for information about the operation. The site you are reading now is an independent educational resource. It is not run by, and does not speak for, any of the agencies involved. It explains what is publicly documented about the case and the federal laws that wildlife prosecutions rely on.

How the Investigation Began

According to testimony the Forest Service gave to a subcommittee of the U.S. House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform on June 19, 2015, the agency saw a trend of illegal activity on National Forest System lands during 2008 and 2009. Reports from the public and other agencies pointed to illegal baiting, illegal taking of black bears and illegal commercial outfitting of hunts. The conduct occurred on federal, state and private land and crossed several jurisdictions, so the Forest Service coordinated with the other affected agencies. From 2009 through 2013 the operation was managed jointly, with each agency keeping supervision of its own officers. Because uniformed patrols were not expected to surface this kind of violation, the agencies decided to use undercover officers.

What Investigators Documented

The participating agencies reported documenting:

The Forest Service later testified that investigators also uncovered commercial sale of black bear parts, closed-season taking, failure to register bear harvests and federal Lacey Act violations. When arrests were announced in February 2013, officials described more than 80 violators. Releases from that time put the number of violations at between 900 and 980.

Federal Cases in Western North Carolina

On June 10, 2013, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of North Carolina announced that ten defendants had been sentenced in federal court. Their offenses were committed in the Nantahala and Pisgah National Forests. They pleaded guilty to charges that included:

Sentences ranged from fines and probation to 15 or 30 days in custody, and several defendants lost their hunting and fishing privileges for two years. Most of these were petty and misdemeanor cases, not felony trafficking prosecutions.

The Forest Service’s 2015 testimony gave a fuller account of its own referrals. It presented 24 individuals to federal prosecutors, and 18 were convicted. Of the remaining six, two had charges dismissed under plea agreements in other federal cases, and four were not charged after Justice Department review. The convictions covered:

Georgia brought its own charges under state law: at the February 2013 announcement, the state reported eight defendants facing 136 state charges.

Questions Raised About the Operation

The operation was examined at a hearing of the House Government Operations Subcommittee in June 2015. The Forest Service testified that the agencies, including the Department of Justice, had agreed in advance that an undercover officer could take non-endangered game if necessary to protect his cover, and that this happened twice during the four years. Defendants challenged the Forest Service’s jurisdiction and argued outrageous government conduct and entrapment. The court denied the jurisdiction and outrageous-conduct motions but let a jury consider entrapment; the jury acquitted on one count and convicted on another. How these defenses work is explained in our article on undercover wildlife operations and entrapment defenses.

The Federal Laws Behind Wildlife Prosecutions

Articles

The Lacey Act: America’s Primary Tool Against Wildlife Trafficking

What 16 U.S.C. § 3372 prohibits, when a violation is a felony and when it is a misdemeanor, false-labeling offenses, and forfeiture.

Endangered Species Act Violations: Criminal Penalties and Federal Enforcement Procedures

ESA crimes are misdemeanors under 16 U.S.C. § 1540(b). How “take” is defined, why felony counts come from companion statutes, and how sentences are set.

Wildlife Trafficking and CITES: How International Treaties Are Enforced in U.S. Courts

CITES appendices, how the ESA and the Lacey Act give the treaty force in U.S. courts, designated ports, and venue in trafficking cases.

How Federal Wildlife Investigations Work

Undercover work, forensic identification, informants, the sources of federal jurisdiction, and how the Sentencing Guidelines treat wildlife offenses.

Undercover Wildlife Operations: Legal Framework and Entrapment Defenses in Federal Cases

Why consensual dealings with an undercover agent raise no Fourth Amendment issue, how entrapment is proved and rebutted, and what was litigated after Operation Something Bruin.